Roll-call vote · Budgetary Control
Discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2023, Section III – Commission, executive agencies and the ninth, tenth and eleventh European Development Funds
A10-0074/2025 - Niclas Herbst - Proposal for a decision
On 7 May 2025 Parliament voted on A10-0074/2025 and adopted it, 412 to 245 with 5 abstentions. 662 of 719 members seated that day have a recorded vote.
How the chamber divided
One dot per member seated on the day, arranged in a hemicycle-style layout from left to right by political group. This does not reproduce individual seat assignments. Colour is how they voted; marks on the outer edge divide the groups, which are named under the chart.
How each group voted
Each bar is one group’s members who voted, split by how they voted. Above it: how many of the group’s members seated that day voted, and the group’s majority - more than half of those voting - if it had one. A group’s members are counted as Parliament’s records place them on the day of the vote. The groups page and member pages go by the site’s member list as it stands now, so their counts can differ where a member has changed group, joined or left. Groups are in the order they sit in the chamber, from left to right, as in the chart above. Non-attached members belong to no group, so no majority is given for them.
How each member voted
Open a category to see its members, listed by group and by surname. “No vote recorded” is not an absence finding: the official result does not distinguish absence from being present without voting.
For - 412
The Left 1
Greens/EFA 49
- Rasmus Andresen
- Jaume Asens Llodrà
- Michael Bloss
- Damian Boeselager
- Gordan Bosanac
- Saskia Bricmont
- Mélissa Camara
- Anna Cavazzini
- David Cormand
- Bas Eickhout (former MEP)
- Daniel Freund
- Alexandra Geese
- Cristina Guarda
- Martin Häusling
- Pär Holmgren
- Alice Kuhnke
- Katrin Langensiepen
- Isabella Lövin
- Ignazio Roberto Marino
- Erik Marquardt
- Tilly Metz
- Ana Miranda Paz
- Hannah Neumann
- Ville Niinistö
- Rasmus Nordqvist
- Maria Ohisalo
- Leoluca Orlando
- Jutta Paulus
- Kira Marie Peter-Hansen
- Vladimir Prebilič
- Terry Reintke
- Diana Riba I Giner
- Nela Riehl
- Mounir Satouri
- Majdouline Sbai
- Lena Schilling
- Benedetta Scuderi
- Virginijus Sinkevičius
- Mārtiņš Staķis
- Nicolae Ștefănuță
- Tineke Strik
- Anna Strolenberg
- Villy Søvndal
- Kai Tegethoff
- Marie Toussaint
- Reinier van Lanschot
- Kim van Sparrentak
- Catarina Vieira
- Thomas Waitz
Socialists & Democrats 115
- Alex Agius Saliba
- Vytenis Povilas Andriukaitis
- Marc Angel
- Lucia Annunziata
- Sakis Arnaoutoglou
- Francisco Assis
- Daniel Attard
- Thomas Bajada
- Laura Ballarín Cereza
- Dragoş Benea
- Robert Biedroń
- Gabriele Bischoff
- Vilija Blinkevičiūtė
- Stefano Bonaccini
- Biljana Borzan
- Udo Bullmann
- Delara Burkhardt
- Gheorghe Cârciu
- José Cepeda
- Estelle Ceulemans
- Mohammed Chahim
- Christophe Clergeau
- Annalisa Corrado
- Vivien Costanzo
- Tobias Cremer
- Andi Cristea
- Antonio Decaro (former MEP)
- Elio di Rupo
- Vasile Dîncu
- Klára Dobrev
- Matthias Ecke
- Jonás Fernández
- Gabriela Firea
- Claire Fita
- André Franqueira Rodrigues
- Niels Fuglsang
- Lina Gálvez
- Iratxe García Pérez
- Jens Geier
- Jean-Marc Germain
- Raphaël Glucksmann
- Isilda Gomes
- Sandra Gómez López
- Bruno Gonçalves
- Sérgio Gonçalves
- Nicolás González Casares
- Giorgio Gori
- Maria Grapini
- Elisabeth Grossmann
- Elisabetta Gualmini
- Hannes Heide
- Alicia Homs Ginel
- Romana Jerković
- François Kalfon
- Marina Kaljurand
- Aurore Lalucq
- Murielle Laurent
- Camilla Laureti
- Javi López
- Juan Fernando López Aguilar
- César Luena
- Giuseppe Lupo
- Cristina Maestre
- Marit Maij
- Claudiu Manda
- Yannis Maniatis
- Pierfrancesco Maran
- Idoia Mendia
- Sven Mikser
- Csaba Molnár
- Alessandra Moretti
- Ştefan Muşoiu
- Victor Negrescu
- Matjaž Nemec
- Dan Nica
- Maria Noichl
- Leire Pajín
- Nikos Papandreou
- Thomas Pellerin-Carlin
- Tsvetelina Penkova
- Pina Picierno
- Tonino Picula
- Evelyn Regner
- René Repasi
- Sabrina Repp
- Thijs Reuten
- Matteo Ricci
- Aodhán Ó Ríordáin
- Marcos Ros Sempere
- Sandro Ruotolo
- Nacho Sánchez Amor
- Elena Sancho Murillo
- Eric Sargiacomo
- Christel Schaldemose
- Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus
- Andreas Schieder
- Rosa Serrano Sierra
- Günther Sidl
- Birgit Sippel
- Krzysztof Śmiszek
- Cecilia Strada
- Marco Tarquinio
- Carla Tavares
- Irene Tinagli
- Bruno Tobback
- Raffaele Topo
- Mihai Tudose
- Nils Ušakovs
- Kathleen van Brempt
- Kristian Vigenin
- Marianne Vind
- Tiemo Wölken
- Lara Wolters
- Alessandro Zan
- Nicola Zingaretti
Renew Europe 70
- Oihane Agirregoitia Martínez
- Abir Al-Sahlani
- Grégory Allione
- Barry Andrews
- Petras Auštrevičius
- Malik Azmani
- Jeannette Baljeu
- Dan Barna
- Stine Bosse
- Gilles Boyer
- Helmut Brandstätter
- Pascal Canfin
- Benoit Cassart
- Olivier Chastel
- Asger Christensen
- Veronika Cifrová Ostrihoňová
- João Cotrim de Figueiredo
- Barry Cowen
- Valérie Devaux
- Engin Eroglu
- Laurence Farreng
- Raquel García Hermida-van der Walle
- Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy
- Andreas Glück
- Charles Goerens
- Sandro Gozi
- Bart Groothuis
- Christophe Grudler
- Svenja Hahn
- Valérie Hayer
- Anna-Maja Henriksson
- Martin Hojsík
- Irena Joveva
- Karin Karlsbro
- Ľubica Karvašová
- Elsi Katainen
- Billy Kelleher
- Fabienne Keller
- Michał Kobosko
- Moritz Körner
- Katri Kulmuni
- Ilhan Kyuchyuk
- Nathalie Loiseau
- Morten Løkkegaard
- Michael McNamara
- Nikola Minchev
- Ciaran Mullooly
- Cynthia Ní Mhurchú
- Ľudovít Ódor
- Jan-Christoph Oetjen
- Urmas Paet
- Hristo Petrov
- Christine Singer
- Marie-Agnes Strack-Zimmermann
- Joachim Streit
- Anna Stürgkh
- Eugen Tomac
- Jana Toom
- Anouk van Brug
- Brigitte van den Berg
- Ana Vasconcelos
- Vlad Vasile-Voiculescu
- Hilde Vautmans
- Marie-Pierre Vedrenne (former MEP)
- Yvan Verougstraete
- Emma Ytterell
- Michal Wiezik
- Lucia Yar
- Stéphanie Yon-Courtin
- Dainius Žalimas
European People's Party 165
- Mika Aaltola
- Maravillas Abadía Jover
- Magdalena Adamowicz
- Georgios Aftias
- Peter Agius
- Pablo Arias Echeverría
- Pascal Arimont
- Bartosz Arłukowicz
- Wouter Beke
- Fredis Beleris
- François-Xavier Bellamy
- Isabel Benjumea Benjumea
- Tom Berendsen (former MEP)
- Stefan Berger
- Alexander Bernhuber
- Ioan-Rareş Bogdan
- Nikolina Brnjac
- Daniel Buda
- Borys Budka
- Andrzej Buła
- Nina Carberry
- David Casa
- Daniel Caspary (former MEP)
- Laurent Castillo (former MEP)
- Caterina Chinnici
- Carmen Crespo Díaz
- Paulo Cunha
- Henrik Dahl
- Dóra Dávid
- Raúl de la Hoz Quintano
- Salvatore de Meo
- Pilar del Castillo Vera
- Paulo do Nascimento Cabral
- Regina Doherty
- Christian Doleschal
- Herbert Dorfmann
- Christian Ehler
- Rosa Estaràs Ferragut
- Gheorghe Falcă
- Marco Falcone
- Jan Farský
- Markus Ferber
- Loucas Fourlas
- Michael Gahler
- Kamila Gasiuk-Pihowicz
- Gabriella Gerzsenyi
- Niels Geuking
- Jens Gieseke
- Borja Giménez Larraz
- Sunčana Glavak
- Christophe Gomart
- Esteban González Pons
- Dirk Gotink
- Hanna Gronkiewicz-Waltz
- Michalis Hadjipantela
- Andrzej Halicki
- Niels Flemming Hansen
- Mircea-Gheorghe Hava
- Niclas Herbst
- Esther Herranz García
- Krzysztof Hetman
- Monika Hohlmeier
- Sérgio Humberto
- Céline Imart
- Adam Jarubas
- Dariusz Joński
- Rasa Juknevičienė
- Sandra Kalniete
- Emmanouil Kefalogiannis
- Seán Kelly
- Sophia Kircher
- Stefan Köhler
- Łukasz Kohut
- Ondřej Kolář
- Kinga Kollár
- Ewa Kopacz
- Andrey Kovatchev
- András Tivadar Kulja
- Eszter Lakos
- Ilia Lazarov
- Isabelle le Callennec
- Jeroen Lenaers
- Janusz Lewandowski
- Miriam Lexmann
- Peter Liese
- Norbert Lins
- Reinhold Lopatka
- Antonio López-Istúriz White
- Péter Magyar (former MEP)
- Lukas Mandl
- Jagna Marczułajtis-Walczak
- Gabriel Mato
- Eva Maydell
- Liudas Mažylis
- David McAllister
- Alexandra Mehnert
- Vangelis Meimarakis
- Eleonora Meleti
- Verena Mertens
- Francisco José Millán Mon
- Dolors Montserrat
- Nadine Morano
- Letizia Moratti
- Dan-Ştefan Motreanu
- Siegfried Mureşan
- Fernando Navarrete Rojas
- Danuše Nerudová
- Elena Nevado del Campo
- Angelika Niebler
- Luděk Niedermayer
- Andrey Novakov
- Mirosława Nykiel
- Nicolás Pascual de la Parte
- Ana Miguel Pedro
- Lídia Pereira
- Sirpa Pietikäinen
- Virgil-Daniel Popescu
- Giusi Princi
- Jacek Protas
- Emil Radev
- Dennis Radtke
- Jüri Ratas
- Karlo Ressler
- Manuela Ripa
- Massimiliano Salini
- Aura Salla
- Paulius Saudargas
- Oliver Schenk
- Christine Schneider (former MEP)
- Andreas Schwab
- Ralf Seekatz
- Bartłomiej Sienkiewicz
- Sven Simon
- Tomislav Sokol
- Susana Solís Pérez
- Liesbet Sommen
- Hélder Sousa Silva
- Davor Ivo Stier
- Michał Szczerba
- Zoltán Tarr (former MEP)
- Ingeborg ter Laak
- Riho Terras
- Romana Tomc
- Matej Tonin
- Flavio Tosi
- Dimitris Tsiodras
- Inese Vaidere
- Adina Vălean
- Adrián Vázquez Lázara
- Loránt Vincze
- Axel Voss
- Elissavet Vozemberg-Vrionidi
- Maria Walsh
- Marion Walsmann
- Michał Wawrykiewicz
- Marta Wcisło
- Andrea Wechsler
- Iuliu Winkler
- Angelika Winzig
- Isabel Wiseler-Lima
- Javier Zarzalejos
- Tomáš Zdechovský
- Bogdan Andrzej Zdrojewski
- Juan Ignacio Zoido Álvarez
- Elżbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska
Patriots for Europe 1
Non-attached 11
Against - 245
The Left 40
- Li Andersson
- Giuseppe Antoci
- Konstantinos Arvanitis
- Manon Aubry
- Pernando Barrena Arza
- Marc Botenga
- Lynn Boylan
- Damien Carême
- Leila Chaibi
- Per Clausen
- Danilo della Valle
- Özlem Demirel
- Sebastian Everding (former MEP)
- Nikolas Farantouris
- Emma Fourreau
- Kathleen Funchion
- Mario Furore
- Estrella Galán
- Hanna Gedin
- Giorgos Georgiou
- Rudi Kennes
- Elena Kountoura
- Mimmo Lucano
- Marina Mesure
- Irene Montero
- Carolina Morace
- João Oliveira
- Younous Omarjee
- Valentina Palmisano
- Nikos Pappas
- Gaetano Pedulla'
- Carola Rackete (former MEP)
- Arash Saeidi
- Ilaria Salis
- Jussi Saramo
- Martin Schirdewan
- Jonas Sjöstedt
- Anthony Smith
- Dario Tamburrano
- Pasquale Tridico
Socialists & Democrats 7
- Johan Danielsson
- Adnan Dibrani
- Sofie Eriksson
- Heléne Fritzon
- Eero Heinäluoma
- Evin Incir
- Ana Catarina Mendes
European People's Party 6
European Conservatives & Reformists 74
- Galato Alexandraki
- Adrian-George Axinia
- Stephen Nikola Bartulica
- Nicolas Bay
- Sergio Berlato
- Adam Bielan
- Tobiasz Bocheński
- Joachim Stanisław Brudziński
- Waldemar Buda
- Stefano Cavedagna
- Carlo Ciccioli
- Alessandro Ciriani
- Giovanni Crosetto
- Elena Donazzan
- Dick Erixon
- Carlo Fidanza
- Pietro Fiocchi
- Emmanouil Fragkos
- Alberico Gambino
- Geadis Geadi
- Chiara Gemma
- Małgorzata Gosiewska
- Paolo Inselvini
- Patryk Jaki
- Nora Junco García
- Mariusz Kamiński
- Fernand Kartheiser
- Rihards Kols
- Ondřej Krutílek
- Jaak Madison
- Lara Magoni
- Marlena Maląg
- Mario Mantovani
- Arkadiusz Mularczyk
- Piotr Müller
- Denis Nesci
- Daniel Obajtek
- Jacek Ozdoba
- Guillaume Peltier
- Michele Picaro
- Gheorghe Piperea
- Daniele Polato
- Reinis Pozņaks
- Nicola Procaccini
- Ruggero Razza
- Bert-Jan Ruissen
- Bogdan Rzońca
- Antonella Sberna
- Diego Solier
- Marco Squarta
- Kristoffer Storm
- Şerban Dimitrie Sturdza
- Beata Szydło
- Dominik Tarczyński
- Claudiu-Richard Târziu
- Georgiana Teodorescu
- Cristian Terheş
- Beatrice Timgren
- Waldemar Tomaszewski
- Francesco Torselli
- Laurence Trochu
- Sebastian Tynkkynen
- Ivaylo Valchev
- Francesco Ventola
- Aurelijus Veryga
- Mariateresa Vivaldini
- Alexandr Vondra
- Veronika Vrecionová
- Maciej Wąsik
- Charlie Weimers
- Jadwiga Wiśniewska
- Anna Zalewska
- Roberts Zīle
- Kosma Złotowski
Patriots for Europe 81
- Mathilde Androuët
- Gerolf Annemans
- Jordan Bardella
- Nikola Bartůšek
- Christophe Bay
- Rachel Blom
- Barbara Bonte
- Paolo Borchia
- Mireia Borrás Pabón
- Marie-Luce Brasier-Clain
- Anna Bryłka
- Tomasz Buczek
- Jorge Buxadé Villalba
- Jaroslav Bžoch
- Anna Maria Cisint
- Marie Dauchy
- Margarita de la Pisa Carrión
- Valérie Deloge
- Tamás Deutsch
- Ton Diepeveen
- Elisabeth Dieringer
- Mélanie Disdier
- Csaba Dömötör
- Marieke Ehlers
- Viktória Ferenc
- Anne-Sophie Frigout
- Angéline Furet
- Kinga Gál
- Jean-Paul Garraud
- Juan Carlos Girauta Vidal
- Catherine Griset
- Enikő Győri
- András Gyürk
- Roman Haider
- Gerald Hauser
- György Hölvényi
- France Jamet
- Virginie Joron
- Ondřej Knotek
- Ondřej Kovařík (former MEP)
- Vilis Krištopans
- Sebastian Kruis
- Tomáš Kubín
- András László
- Afroditi Latinopoulou
- Fabrice Leggeri
- Julien Leonardelli
- Thierry Mariani
- Georg Mayer
- Tiago Moreira de Sá
- Jana Nagyová
- Aleksandar Nikolic
- Philippe Olivier
- Aldo Patriciello
- Gilles Pennelle
- Pascale Piera
- Pierre Pimpie
- Jaroslava Pokorná Jermanová
- Julie Rechagneux
- André Rougé
- Julien Sanchez
- Silvia Sardone
- Ernő Schaller-Baross
- Raffaele Stancanelli
- Petra Steger
- Sebastiaan Stöteler (former MEP)
- António Tânger Corrêa
- Hermann Tertsch
- Pierre-Romain Thionnet
- Rody Tolassy
- Isabella Tovaglieri
- Filip Turek (former MEP)
- Matthieu Valet
- Tom Vandendriessche
- Roberto Vannacci
- Alexandre Varaut
- Annamária Vicsek
- Harald Vilimsky
- Anders Vistisen (former MEP)
- Séverine Werbrouck
- Auke Zijlstra
Europe of Sovereign Nations 22
- Christine Anderson
- Anja Arndt
- René Aust
- Zsuzsanna Borvendég
- Irmhild Boßdorf
- Markus Buchheit
- Petr Bystron
- Ivan David
- Siegbert Frank Droese
- Tomasz Froelich
- Petras Gražulis
- Marc Jongen
- Alexander Jungbluth
- Mary Khan
- Sarah Knafo
- Rada Laykova
- Milan Mazurek
- Hans Neuhoff
- Alexander Sell
- Stanislav Stoyanov
- Marcin Sypniewski
- Petar Volgin
Non-attached 15
Abstained - 5
European People's Party 4
European Conservatives & Reformists 1
No vote recorded - 57
The Left 5
Greens/EFA 4
Socialists & Democrats 14
- Katarina Barley
- Brando Benifei
- Maria Guzenina
- Hana Jalloul Muro
- Pierre Jouvet
- Bernd Lange
- Costas Mavrides
- Nora Mebarek
- Javier Moreno Sánchez
- Dario Nardella
- Emma Rafowicz
- Chloé Ridel
- Marta Temido
- Marko Vešligaj
Renew Europe 5
European People's Party 13
- Hildegard Bentele
- Krzysztof Brejza
- Sebastião Bugalho
- Lena Düpont
- Alma Ezcurra Almansa
- Radan Kanev
- Martine Kemp
- Fulvio Martusciello
- Roberta Metsola
- Pekka Toveri
- Sabine Verheyen
- Manfred Weber
- Željana Zovko